List Only

Is Greg Maddux on your list of the top ten pitchers of all-time? Why or why not?

Not just dominating, but also consider career totals and averages.

Public Comments

1. yes right behind clemens, seaver, ryan, david cone, david wells, and andy pettie
2. hmmm I think so... he's the best mind in the game... I love how he plays chess with the batters...
3. Yes, somewhere between #4 and #9.
4. Being the age that I am and also the fan I am I've watched the game since the early 70's and I would actually say that since then he's been the best out of all. No other pitcher has had that kind of pinpoint control and the streak of 15 wins a season for all those years is amazing given the fact he throws only 80-84 miles an hour.
5. Nope. These are the ones I would have for sure in the top ten- Cy Young Nolan Ryan Sandy Koufax Grover Cleveland Alexander Rollie Fingers Catfish Hunter As for today's pitchers, several are better than Greg Maddux. Randy Johnson Roger Clemens Curt Shilling Mariano Rivera Tom Glavin Yes. I have always thought Tommy was a better pitcher than Greg. I guess it's just a matter of opinion. Even though I don't like Roger Clemens personally, he is still the better pitcher. By the way, these are in no particular order.
6. Yes. 347 career wins will do that... he's second only to Roger Clemens in the modern day era, ahead of guys like Seaver, Ryan, Carlton, Sutton, and Niekro. He's also exactly 1 day younger than me...
7. yes. The way he dominated in the mid 1990's was koufax like.
8. all time, no. No pitcher since Bob Gibson retired cracks the top 10.
9. If you compare his career totals and awards, Greg is better than most pitchers. He has won 4 Cy young awards and 17 gold gloves.He did all of that without the help of steroids.
10. yes hes amazing to be calm under pressure with anyone up... he has great composure and just like these super-breaking balls... then his ability to locate a spot and hit it... i think hes up first on the list
11. Top 5 easily.
12. Yes because he's a beast, he's clean, he's a man, and he was a Cub.
13. he is because he is the only pitcher who isn't juiced.